Most just-in-time part requirements
are typically associated with only high volume production
manufacturers. For one mold and die shop, however, JIT
has become a way of life to meet customer mold and die
demands. According
to Rob Olsen, manufacturing manager at Model Die &
Mold, Inc., Grand Rapids, MI, "What use to take us
16 - 18 weeks to produce a mold, now, at times, has
turned around to the customer in just 12 - 14 weeks - or,
in some cases, less."
Model Die & Mold is a large die
and mold shop with a diversity of customers. They produce
plastic injection and compression molds and dies for a
number of world wide manufacturers in home and garden,
medical, computer, military, automotive, and electronics
markets. Annual sales are approximately 12 million.
MD&Ms customers demand
molds with short turn-around times and sometimes with
extremely complex shapes that are designed with many
hard-to-produce thin, deep ribs.
Olsen said, "After we receive
the CAD file to produce the mold from the customer, we
carefully go over it to see if we can produce the part as
it was rendered. We also see if we can make minor changes
that will save production time, but will not affect the
quality of the end part. We might find a rib doesnt
need to be squared off, saving EDM time. Or where
possible, we can design the rib to be thicker - very deep
and thin ribs are hard to fill in an injection mold.
After the mold has finally been approved by the customer,
we manufacture it the most economical way using CNC
milling and EDM machines."
To meet demanding customer deadlines,
Model Die and Mold replaced four older CNC EDM sinkers
with three EDM Solutions Titan EDM Sinkers. Olsen said
because of the Titan's speed and efficiency, the three
could do the work of the previous four (they also just
installed a fourth EDM Solutions Polaris machine).
"To find the right sinker, we looked
at many different parameters: initial purchase price
versus performance, style of machine, overall machine
capabilities, tank size, and, most importantly, service
and support. We had demos from just about every major
manufacturer. Only two machines met our criteria. For
performance, the two were just about equal. However,
compared in cost, the nearest competitor's purchase price
was nearly 50% more than the EDM Solutions Titan machines
that we finally chose," Olsen remarked.
The three Titan EDM machines have
tank sizes of 50 x 80 inches, which were about the same
size as two of the four machines that were
replaced. However, the Titan models offer greater X, Y,
and Z axis travel (when compared to other machines with
similar tank sizes), giving them greater part size
capability. This also helps the company to improve upon
multiple part setups, increasing their overall
"green light burn time." The Polaris has a
smaller 40 x 60 inch tank size. On two of the Titan
sinkers, a C-axis capability has been added.
The Titan machines are in operation
24 hours a day and usually five to six hours on Saturday.
Some of the work is unattended where the operator sets up
the machine for automatic cutting. However, Olsen said
that "we tend to push the envelopes of all of our
equipment, and I'd rather have an operator around just in
case there are problems. Usually, one machinist can
operate two machines."
Although 95% of their mold work is
one-of-a-kind, and Olsen said its difficult to precisely
quantify time savings over the older sinkers, he feels
that the EDM Solutions machines provide roughly a 30 to
40 percent savings in total output.
Olsen said that there are a lot of
reasons for these savings. Because the Titans and Polaris
machines use the very latest EDM technology with precise
CNC controls and power supplies, they are faster overall.
Plus, because they get higher precision by using
Heidenhain CNC controls, they can produce much better
part surface finishing, saving time in benchworking.
Olsen also likes the control's conversational and
user-friendly nature.
Electrode usage has also been
reduced. For example, instead of using an average of
three electrodes on a typical burn, now one or two
(depending on the mold) are used. A reduction on
electrode usage saves CNC electrode machining costs.
graphite cost and time spend at the EDM.
MD&M primarily uses P-20 steel
with a Rockwell C hardness in the 28 - 38 range, as well
as aluminum with inserted areas using Beryllium, Moldmax,
Protherm and other materials.
EDM Solutions Titan sinkers have a
maximum workpiece weight of 31,200 lbs., with a maximum
ram capacity of 1,100 lbs., and X, Y, and Z axis travel
of 52 x 28 x 18 inches. Polaris sinkers allow a maximum
workpiece weight of 6,600 lbs., with a maximum ram
capacity of 440 lbs., and X, Y, Z axis travel of 24 x 20
x 16 inches.
For more information,
please consult these links (for more up to date
information than is mentioned in the article):
|